Although cats are very playful and curious, they can be very picky when it comes to choosing a cat toy. To make your cat play with a certain toy, what you can do is spread some catnip or give her treats and encourage her to play with the toy. One of the best toys that your cat will love is wand and teaser toys. These toys are the best to keep your cat physically active and mentally curious. They will love to paw and chase and you will have fun watching your cat pounce with happiness.